• Banner 1
  • Banner 2
  • Banner 3

Granato's Pizza: A Beloved Spot for Pizza Lovers in New Philadelphia

Granato's Pizza, located in the heart of New Philadelphia, Ohio, offers a homey, mom-and-pop experience for pizza lovers. Renowned for its delicious, thick-crust pizza with a unique sweet sauce, it has captured the hearts of many locals. Customers appreciate the generous portions and the inviting atmosphere, making it a perfect spot for families. While recent reviews indicate inconsistencies since the new ownership, including complaints about burnt offerings and additional credit card fees, the overall reception remains positive, with loyal patrons expressing their satisfaction with the flavors and pricing. Granato's Pizza is a cozy neighborhood gem worth exploring.

Granato's Pizza at a glance

  • Address 1320 4th St NW F, New Philadelphia, OH 44663, United States
  • Phone +1 330-343-5577
  • Restaurant type Pizza restaurant , Italian restaurant .
  • Popular for Popular for dinner .

Photos & Gallery

Granato's Pizza: Reviews & Ratings

Enoch Wright
3

Updated review since new ownership: Granato's new ownership seems to burn the pizza and cheese sticks every order. I was a weekly customer before, but now my same order is $4+ more and always burnt... Plus credit card fees are a cost of doing business, stop adding a fee on. I'm curious to see what happens with Park Street being in Dover soon. Old review: 5 stars. Granatos is by far my favorite pizza. Highly recommended.

Keith B
5

Amazing pizza. I didn't even know they were right down the road till I was almost 40. They're easily my favorite pizza place and have great prices

Craig Diodati
5

Ate there for the first time with the whole family. I was very satisfied. Will definitely get more of our business

Rai Raz
5

First time trying this, been living walking distance away and finally got to try it! Very interesting to have the sweet sauce like that, love the thicker crust, very mom and pop shop like experience. Delicious pizza, will try again! Lower for service as due to using a card they add credit card charge. That should be included into the price right away. That is just my opinion as some might be counting on paying exact amount!

William Jones
5

They make consistently delicious pizza.

S Murphy
4

It's great, if you like very light sauce. The last time we said hey, we have been getting like missing sauce, just dough. So they asked if we wanted extra sauce. We said no just normal, but more than missing big blank dough spots lol. Well apparently we have to ask for extra sauce. it's weird, don't have this problem anywhere else....their salads are not typical pizza place salad, leaves a little to be desired, very small and priced like a medium salad, few toppings. Subs are great! Homemade taste!

Colt Albrecht
5

Wife and I tried Granato's Pizza for the first time after seeing good reviews. They did not disappoint. Great pizza, sauce and friendly staff when we picked up.

Location

  • Granato's Pizza
    Granato's Pizza
    1320 4th St NW F, New Philadelphia, OH 44663, United States Hotline: +1 330-343-5577

Welcome to Granato's Pizza, a delightful gem nestled in the heart of New Philadelphia, Ohio. This establishment has captured the attention of many pizza enthusiasts, each having their unique tales of experience, be it an exciting first visit or a long-standing weekly tradition.

Located at 1320 4th St NW F, Granato's Pizza is the epitome of a classic mom-and-pop shop, offering a warm and inviting atmosphere. Guests often rave about the unique sweet sauce that sets their pizzas apart, paired with a satisfying, thick crust that adds to the overall enjoyment. Whether you’re a local or just passing through, this charming eatery serves up mouthwatering pizza that keeps patrons coming back for more.

Recent reviews highlight a mix of experiences under the new ownership. While some loyal customers express disappointment regarding inconsistencies—touching on issues like burnt offerings and additional credit card fees—many continue to praise Granato's pizza for its flavorful offerings and appealing prices. Customers like Keith B describe it as their favorite pizza place, showcasing a community that values quality and affordability.

For families seeking a casual dining experience, Granato's Pizza is an excellent choice. Reviewers such as Craig Diodati appreciate the satisfaction that comes with sharing their pizza around the table, while others, like Rai Raz, enjoy the nostalgic vibes that this establishment provides.

Granato's Pizza stands strong as a local favorite, committed to delivering delicious dishes while navigating the challenges that every restaurant faced, especially during transitions. It’s an inviting space that offers more than just pizza; it’s about the experience, community, and flavors that linger long after the last bite. If you haven't yet experienced the charm and taste of Granato's Pizza, it's time to make your way there and see what the buzz is all about!

For inquiries or orders, don't hesitate to contact them at +1 330-343-5577. Enjoy your pizza adventure!

Business Information

  • Accessibility
    • Has wheelchair-accessible car park
    • Has wheelchair-accessible entrance
  • Service options
    • Offers takeaway
  • Payments
    • Accepts credit cards
    • Accepts debit cards
    • Accepts NFC mobile payments
    • Credit cards